Party of 4 look over the table of notes and dice as they play a TTRPG. Discussing how to balance the game

Balancing Encounters and Challenges

As a Dungeon Master, one of your primary responsibilities is to create exciting and challenging encounters for your players. However, it can be challenging to balance encounters and challenges to ensure that they are not too easy or too difficult for your players. In this post, we'll provide some tips on how to balance encounters and challenges.  



Know Your Players Before you start designing encounters, it's essential to know your players' strengths, weaknesses, and playstyles. If your players are combat-oriented, they may prefer more challenging battles. Alternatively, if your players prefer role-playing, you may want to focus on encounters that require negotiation, investigation, or diplomacy. 


Consider Your Players' Abilities While challenge ratings (CR) can be a helpful guide when designing encounters, they are not always accurate for every group of players. Some players may have stronger characters or more experienced players who can handle more challenging encounters than others. Therefore, it's essential to consider your players' abilities when creating encounters. 


One way to do this is to track how well your players handle combat encounters. Take note of how quickly they defeat monsters and whether they take a lot of damage in the process. This can help you gauge how challenging encounters should be for your group.


Another factor to consider is the level of optimization in your group. If your players have min-maxed their characters to be exceptionally powerful, you may need to create more challenging encounters to keep them engaged. 


Use Action Economy The action economy is the number of actions each side has in a combat encounter. In general, the side with more actions tends to have an advantage. So, if your players are outnumbered, you may want to give them powerful allies or environmental advantages to balance the encounter. 


Adjust on the Fly No matter how much planning you do, encounters can still go wrong. Sometimes, encounters that seem easy on paper can turn out to be deadly. Be prepared to adjust encounters on the fly by reducing or increasing the number of enemies, modifying their stats, or changing the environment. And you know - its okay to not follow the rules exactly as they are written. 


Test Your Encounters The best way to balance encounters is to test them. Run test encounters with your players or use online encounter builders to see how challenging an encounter will be. This will help you adjust encounters before your players face them in-game. Our own homebrews have been battletested, played & replayed - and we still find areas for improvement! 


Balancing encounters and challenges is a crucial part of being a Dungeon Master. By knowing your players, considering their abilities, using action economy, adjusting on the fly, and testing your encounters, you can create exciting and challenging encounters that your players will enjoy.


Good luck, and happy gaming!


Back to blog